Tuesday, July 23, 2013

RDG: Red Data Girl Final Thoughts--Supernatural is the New Normal

RDG: Red Data Girl Review Screenshot 1

While is has more than it's share of missteps, RDG is still an entertaining series that should not be ignored by fans of the genre.

RDG: Red Data Girl Review Screenshot 2 RDG: Red Data Girl Review Screenshot 3

Taking its inspiration from Shinto mythology, RDG is a slow-burn kind of story, taking deliberate steps to set up its characters and world as the foundation it builds on with each story arc. The plot follows Suzuhara Izumiko, a girl who is next in line to inherit the mysterious powers of the Himegami. However, lack of explanation about this has lead to Izumiko feeling over-sheltered and wishing that she had the life of a normal girl. From there, the show is a series of discoveries about herself and the world of spiritually powerful people, with increasing levels of danger each time.

RDG: Red Data Girl Review Screenshot 4 RDG: Red Data Girl Review Screenshot 5

The show spends long stretches of time letting the characters talk to each other and chew over the scenery, which can be either an enhancement or a detriment depending on your personal taste. I thought that it worked well in this particular show, since it provided a solid look at the characters before the inevitable magic and supernatural themes popped up. The result is something that is more character driven than your average supernatural piece, focusing more on how the characters relate to this mysterious world than on explaining the world itself.

RDG: Red Data Girl Review Screenshot 6 RDG: Red Data Girl Review Screenshot 7

Two major players in the plot, twins Mayura and Manatsu, play the role of Izumiko's first close friends who are aware of her secret, but their own powers and motivations prior to meeting her make for a good early example of the world's "everyone's out for themselves" philosophy. Getting into further details would require spoilers, so I'll leave it at that. Takayanagi, the main rival of the show, doesn't make as many appearances, but has the kind of sleazy aura of a politician, and his influence is felt across the later story arcs even before he steps in. And then there's Izumiko, whose desire to be normal clashes with her latent powers. Innocuous statements become powerful spells when she says them, and she can't even make a change to her wardrobe or her routine without incurring the wrath or interest of the powerful beings around her. This is the cause for most of the conflict in the show.

RDG: Red Data Girl Review Screenshot 8 RDG: Red Data Girl Review Screenshot 9

But the relationship that's given the most weight in the show is the one between Miyuki and Izumiko, who are also the Designated Romantic Couple™. I wasn't happy with this at all at the start of the show, since Miyuki is characterized as the kind of person who takes out his frustrations on those who don't deserve it, but his growing resolve throughout the series plus his banter with Izumiko warmed me up to the idea of them as a couple by the end. Miyuki's character growth is almost completely tied with his level of magic proficiency as well, so he goes from a whiner with no power at the beginning to someone using his decent level of magic power to protect what's important to him at the end.

RDG: Red Data Girl Review Screenshot 10 RDG: Red Data Girl Review Screenshot 11

If this review has sounded vague so far, that's because of one of two reasons: 1) I'm trying to avoid spoilers, or 2) I don't understand it myself. A lot of things in RDG are left unexplained, or the show acts like a confusing topic was perfectly clear. By the end of the show, I still had a lot of lingering questions, some bigger than others: What are the Himegami's powers, exactly? Why does everyone she meets become obsessed with her? Is everyone on the school campus competing for the World Heritage title, or are only a few students aware? Why was the "real" student council president never seen of mentioned again after the episode that made a big deal about his power over the school? What does someone get out of "winning" the World Heritage title? Similarly, why were Mayura and Manatsu competing with Takayanagi for it? And is Masumi really a sprit or something bigger?

RDG: Red Data Girl Review Screenshot 12 RDG: Red Data Girl Review Screenshot 13

And so on. To RDG's credit, these questions came to mind after I would finish watching an episode. The show does a great job of drawing you in, so there were no problems with suspension of disbelief when I was viewing it. However, once I was away from the pretty animation and intriguing characters, the unexplained parts and holes in the plot became obvious and bothered me. I'm always disappointed when a plot starts to fall apart at the slightest scrutiny. It feels like this was a problem with the source material rather than the adaptation, because the show does seem to go out of its way to maintain the mood when the plot isn't there. Unfortunately, this doesn't always work out. One example is when an episode ends on an emotional cliffhanger involving the Himegami, but by the next episode, the problem had resolved itself offscreen, missing a great opportunity for at least one good scene. All of that said, it's completely possible that my questions about the plot and problems with the focus were caused by my lack of knowledge about Shinto mythology. Maybe then RDG would make more sense, because it was a show I enjoyed even as I became more confused.

RDG: Red Data Girl Review Screenshot 14

While it wasn't a standout title from the Spring 2013 season, RDG is still a solid show. P.A. Works delivered stunning and consistent visuals with movie-quality nature backgrounds. Even with my confusion over some of the plot details, I enjoyed and appreciated the story's ability to show restraint early on for better payoffs later. It also deserves praise for picking a stopping point that tied up most of the ongoing conflicts that the show presented, which doesn't happen often enough in anime adaptations. The show also boasts surprisingly good character development, especially on the romance side, which I'm mentioning again because it's really hard to win me back once I've decided I don't like a character! I definitely recommend this show to fans of supernatural and character-driven series. The combination offers something a little bit different from the norm, but if you're willing to take time for RDG, it's got a facinating world waiting to be uncovered.

Images from Hulu.com and Funimation.com.

4 comments:

  1. Questions, questions, let's see...

    - The Himegami's power is to mix elements of the human and spirit worlds. It is mentioned repeatedly that only a few humans remain that can bridge the two worlds. The twins can only do this with help from the other side (Masumi). My understanding was the Takayanagi is similarly limited, except that his "help" from the other side is not voluntary but instead is coerced by enslaving the spirit of an animal before it dies. Izumiko is the only one we see who can freely cross into the spirit world on her own, and that's even before she comes into her full power.

    - Everyone who meets Himegami is obsessed? I don't recall this. Hardly anyone meets her on screen.

    - Everyone is competing, in principle, but only a notable few are thought to be serious candidates.

    - What do they get from winning? I'm not sure exactly what the advertised payout is, but something to the effect of providing and preserving whatever the candidate needs in order to maintain contact with the spirit world. This may or may not be something you'd want to win. If I understood her correctly, Himegami said that when she won it previously they removed and preserved her ovaries and brain for the future benefit of humanity. Yuck. Some winner's prize.

    - What were Mayura and Manatsu hoping to get out of it? I think they were hoping for assistance in preserving their contact with Masumi. Otherwise it would fade or be broken as they grew apart.

    - Masumi apparently was an emanation of a more powerful spirit that remained bound. I have no idea how/why he manifested as the third of the triplets originally. Perhaps this is something that recurred every few generations, tying the family to the shrine?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks for tackling my questions! I'm assuming that you've read the books then, since I'm going off of what the show presented and some of the things you mentioned weren't clear in the show.

    - Okay, that makes a lot more sense. The show left this in the dark and never bothered to clarify what the Himegami's powers were actually for. I was leaning in the direction of what you said, but while trying to maintain the "mystery" the show tripped up and made it vague instead. Because of that I wasn't sure if my assumption was even on the right track.

    - Sorry, my wording was a bit off. I meant that everyone who meets Izumiko gets "obsessed" in some capacity, either wanting her all for themselves (like with Wamiya) or to use her power for their own ends (Takayanagi, Masumi). This ties into the first question, and what you said about her powers shows why others would be so interested in her.

    - The show could've made that clearer then, because it seemed like everyone Izumiko was on speaking terms with in that school was involved somehow, which is why I was confused whether the school was a cover or a "special" school that only existed for one purpose.

    - Ew. That sucks. So it's possible that they could be tricking the candidates into thinking it's something that they want when in reality it could go against their wishes "for the good of the whole" or something like that?

    - That tied into my previous question, but that's clearer now. And they seem to have worked out that problem by the end of the show, so I guess it's a moot point now anyway.



    - I can see that. I think it was the "dream of the dragon" thing that tripped me up.


    Thanks again, this makes a lot more sense now.

    ReplyDelete
  3. From my research, the central problem of RDG was trying to fit in too much plot from its source novel series into a 13 ep series. In fact, they even left out content from the final 6th novel which wraps up most questions about the Himegami.

    To spoil things for you, The Himegami is the divine spirit of Future Izumiko.

    Specifically, minuetto from myanimelist read the novels and found out:

    Izumiko had extraordinary high spiritual power. Many desired her power and because of this she ended up destroying all humans including herself. At the moment her body was destroyed, she found that she traveled back to thousand generations in the past. During her ‘thousand of generations’ journey, she was called by/obtained many names such as ’11 Faced Kannon’ and ‘Himegami’ is the name used among Yamabushis.

    The second Izumiko was killed and used as specimen. Even though she was declared ‘World Heritage’ and as the result, her brain and ovaries were preserved, the destruction of humanity couldn’t be avoided.

    Finally here we have the third Izumiko whom this show is all about. Her braids (to seal her power), the establishment of Houjou Academy, Students that she met at this academy, and especially the existence of Miyuki are new to Himegami. (That’s why Himegami is especially interested in Miyuki.).'

    All events such as the founding of Hojo High and even Miyuki’s existence were planned by Yukariko, Yukimasa and his Yamabushi network to prevent the end of the world for the 3rd time.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I see! That's really interesting. I definitely agree that the show was trying to put in too much plot without enough explanation in that case. That's really too bad; if this had been another cour longer (at 26 episodes) maybe it would've been able to cover it better. Of course, P.A. Works has it's own schedule, and decisions aren't always made on a basis of what is best for the adaptation, so I'm happy with what we got.

    ReplyDelete